Don’t buy Israeli-haters’ lies about reporter – Latest News
Former MSNBC host Mehdi Hasan made an astonishing declare final week on the “Together for Palestine” rally in London’s Wembley Stadium.
“Two-hundred and seventy: That’s how many Palestinian journalists Israel has killed in Gaza,” he advised the cheering crowd of 12,000.
“More than were killed in the First World War, the Second World War, the Korean War, the Vietnam War, the Iraq War — COMBINED!”
What an unimaginable statistic. It appears not possible that 5 bloody wars — which killed not less than 110 million people throughout the globe — induced the deaths of fewer reporters than have occurred within the tiny Gaza Strip within the final two years.
If Hasan’s declare sounds off, it’s as a result of he’s mendacity.
He is knowingly repeating a grotesque falsehood that doesn’t go the sniff check, and that any respected journalist would dismiss upon two minutes of fact-checking.
It’s not simply Hasan. This preposterous factoid has been spreading across the Internet for some time and is attributed to reporter Nick Turse, who revealed it in a paper on a Brown University web site.
That source could be enough for a journalist of Hasan’s caliber, however a temporary have a look at Turse’s footnote exhibits that he obtained his data from a webpage for the “Freedom Forum,” a First Amendment advocacy group.
The Freedom Forum — which ran the defunct “Newseum” — options on its web site a “Journalists Memorial” database, which lists reporters who’ve died within the line of obligation since 1837.
But the Journalists Memorial doesn’t even current itself as an authoritative compendium of all reporters killed in motion.
It lists some reporters, largely American and British.
The memorial counts a grand whole of two reporters as having been killed in World War I, which is considerably much less than the quantity of well-known poets killed in that struggle.
It lists 66 reporters who died in World War II, a battle through which roughly 85 million people died.
It counts no Chinese, German or Japanese reporters, and lists solely two French and two Soviet reporters.
Get opinions and commentary from our columnists
Subscribe to our every day Post Opinion e-newsletter!
Thanks for signing up!
It doesn’t rely any of the a whole bunch of Yiddish-language reporters killed within the Holocaust, or any of the Cambodian journalists murdered by the Khmer Rouge.
No accountable grownup would cite this information in good religion, however Hasan isn’t the one one doing so.
Francesca Albanese, the UN “special rapporteur” on Palestine, says it all of the time, as does Al Jazeera.
Chris Hedges, broadly hailed on the left because the conscience of American journalism, unblinkingly repeats this libel.
Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) posted it on X.
The different aspect of the ledger, particularly the quantity of Palestinian journalists who’ve been killed, can also be extremely suspect.
An monumental quantity of these “journalists” have been recognized as both carefully affiliated with Hamas, or outright Hamas militants.
Reporters Without Borders mourned the death of “journalist” Abdullah al-Jamal, a freelance reporter who wrote sometimes for Al Jazeera.
He was killed when Israeli particular forces stormed his home, the place he was retaining three hostages.
Nevertheless, The Guardian included al-Jamal in a picture unfold of murdered Palestinian journalists.
Anas al-Sharif’s video reporting for Al Jazeera made him the “face of the war in Gaza,” per CNN.
His death in August 2025 was met by an worldwide outcry.
But Israel supplied substantial proof that al-Sharif was an lively member of Hamas and, in reality, a cell chief in a guided-rocket platoon.
He was photographed being embraced by former Hamas commander Yahya Sinwar.
Fact is, in the event you’re reporting from Gaza, chances are high high that you simply’re one way or the other in mattress with Hamas, both as a collaborator or a soldier utilizing a “Press” vest as cowl.
And that’s been true even earlier than the struggle: The Foreign Press Association, the oldest and largest group for international correspondents, has long protested the stress and threats of violence that Hamas routinely imposes on visiting journalists.
In a 2014 assertion, the FPA denounced the “blatant, incessant, forceful and unorthodox” strategies that Hamas makes use of to control the dissemination of data out and in of Gaza.
Professionals who’ve labored within the area know that Hamas, a totalitarian regime, is not going to allow “neutral” observers (and even support staff) to exist in Gaza.
The Hamas propaganda machine has been working full steam since Oct. 7, with the help of its Fifth Column within the West.
It has promulgated lies about the bombing of hospitals, the concentrating on of kids, the outbreak of famine, massacres at support websites and a “genocidal” death toll 10 occasions bigger than what Hamas itself studies.
The fog of struggle inevitably generates uncertainty, and that’s no totally different in Gaza.
But outright lies corresponding to Hasan’s about the unprecedented deaths of journalists in Gaza shine so brightly that they offer a beacon by which we will start to discern reality.
Seth Barron is a member of The Post Editorial Board. X: @sethbarronnyc
